Loading your content...
Loading your content...
Explore how accident severity affects car value, repair vs sell decisions, paperwork in South Africa and practical tips to maximise offers for damaged vehicles.
Structural and mechanical damage have the biggest negative impact on offers.
If repairs exceed ~50% of market value, selling to a specialist is often preferable.
Nationwide towing, finance settlement and deregistration shape final outcomes.
The impact of accident severity on car value depends on how much structural, mechanical and cosmetic damage a vehicle has sustained. In South Africa, buyers and insurers treat minor repairs, moderate structural damage and write-offs very differently - and each level changes market demand and pricing. This guide explains the main value drivers, provides practical examples in R, and helps owners decide whether to repair or sell a damaged vehicle.
Quick note: For many owners in Johannesburg, Cape Town and Durban, the most relevant question is whether repair costs exceed the remaining market value. If repair estimates are a large percentage of market value, selling to a specialist buyer can be faster and lower risk than pursuing repairs.
| Damage type | Typical impact on offers | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Minor cosmetic (bumpers, lights) | Low to moderate reduction | Easily repairable; good resale demand if structural/mechanical sound |
| Moderate structural (panel alignment, suspension) | Significant reduction | Repairs are costlier and affect long-term reliability perception |
| Severe structural/write-off | Large reduction / salvage-only | Often declared insurer write-off; retail resale limited to rebuilders or parts market |
| Flood or fire damage | High reduction; sensitive market | Corrosion or electrical faults can be hidden and costly to fix |
Deciding to repair or sell depends on repair cost estimates versus the vehicle's pre-accident and post-repair market value. A practical guideline in South Africa is to compare repair cost to the car's market value (not just market asking price).
| Repair cost (estimate) | Likely retained value after repair | Decision guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Under 20% of market value | High - repairs often justified | Repair if you plan to keep driving the car |
| 20%-50% of market value | Moderate - resale may be hampered by history | Consider selling to a specialist buyer; get multiple quotes |
| Over 50% of market value | Low - often uneconomic to repair | Selling for salvage or to a cash buyer is usually preferable |
Example (illustrative): a 2014 hatch with estimated market value R80,000 faces R45,000 in structural repairs. Because repair cost exceeds 50% of market value, many owners choose to sell to a specialist or the salvage market rather than fund repairs. Figures are examples only and will vary by model, location and market demand.
For a practical overview of what we buy and our approach to damaged vehicles, see our Sell Damaged Cars page and learn more about how our service supports owners on the How it works page.
Specialist buyers and salvage firms typically follow the same basic steps: inspection or photos, a condition-based offer, paperwork handling and collection. For South African owners, services that include free nationwide towing and assistance with deregistration reduce complexity and speed up payment.
South African sellers should ensure the correct transfer and deregistration steps are followed. If the car is under finance, the lender must be informed: sales proceeds may need to be used to settle the outstanding balance before transfer. Buyers handling paperwork typically assist with deregistration and transfer, but confirm which documents they will complete for you.
Important: Always verify identity and bank details when accepting an offer and receiving payment. If your vehicle is still financed, request written confirmation from the buyer about how the finance settlement and transfer will be handled.
If your vehicle does not run, specialist services such as those described on the Sell Non-Running Car page can provide offers that account for towing and salvage costs.
After collection the buyer usually completes the deregistration and transfer paperwork and moves the vehicle to a repairer, recycler or dismantler depending on condition. Payment timing varies by buyer: many reputable South African services release payment on collection or shortly after paperwork is processed. Always obtain a written receipt and proof of transfer.
- Urban example: A Cape Town owner with moderate front-end damage may find local repair quotes lower than in remote areas, but resale value drops because repair history is recorded. Getting competitive offers from nationwide buyers can reveal whether selling is more cost-effective.
- Fleet example: Small business fleets in Johannesburg that experience repeated write-offs often prioritise quick cash offers and free towing to minimise downtime and administrative burden.
For an overview of our buying criteria and how we manage damaged vehicles nationwide, review the company homepage: Sell Your Damaged Car. That page explains nationwide coverage including Johannesburg, Cape Town and Durban, free towing, and how transparent offers are calculated.
Seasoned automotive specialists dedicated to helping you turn your damaged or non-running vehicle into cash fast and hassle-free.
Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only. Product availability, pricing, and specifications are subject to change. Always verify current details on the retailer's website before making a purchase. We may earn affiliate commissions from qualifying purchases.
Get answers to common questions about Damage Types
Need a tow? We got you
Get a cash offer within 24h!
Somewhere remote? No problem!